Butterbeer Creamsicles Recipe

This butterbeer creamsicle recipe is an essential for any Harry Potter fan!

Butterbeer Creamsicles Recipe
Servings: 5 -6 creamsicles
Author: Katie Clark
  • 1 cup vanilla ice cream
  • 1 tablespoons butterscotch divided
  • 1 teaspoon imitation butter flavoring
  • 1/2 cup cream soda
  • 1 pinch of salt
  • 1/3 cup cool whip
  1. In a small bowl, mix together cool whip and 1 tablespoon butterscotch topping.
  2. In another bowl, mix together vanilla ice cream, 1 tablespoon butterscotch topping, butter flavoring, and 1/2 cup cream soda. It will likely turn somewhat liquid-y.
  3. Spoon about 1 to 1 1/2 tablespoons of the cool whip mixture into each popsicle mold.
  4. Then, spoon the cream soda mixture into the rest of the popsicle mold, filling to the top.
  5. Place in refrigerator overnight.
  6. When you are ready to eat, run hot water over the outside of the mold for about 5 seconds or so. This is essential to making sure your creamsicle slides out. Otherwise, the popsicle stick may come out without anything on it!


My love for Harry Potter started back in grade school. I remember that my friend, Cortney, first told me about them, and I thought, “That sounds stupid.” Fortunately I corrected my initial thoughts quickly, and I was instantly drawn into the magical world of Harry Potter.

I anxiously awaited the released of each new book, and when they were made into movies, I diligently attended the midnight premieres. I remember standing in lines at Barnes and Noble to get the next book in the series for hours, and then staying up for a few more hours afterwards to start in on the book. I really believe there’s been few series that have captivated people as much as Harry Potter did. Forrest loves Harry Potter as well, and we definitely have duplicated copies of the books on our shelf.

I remember in 7th grade, my English teacher banned me from counting Harry Potter on reading minutes because I kept reading them, and she wanted me to “broaden” my reading selections. It was totally lame.

Like most people, I thought that butterbeer sounded spectacular. And obviously there are many recipes out there for it now – I hope to go to the Wizarding World of Harry Potter someday to try the kind they serve.

When Marissa from Rae Gun Ramblings announced that she was looking for people to participate in her annual Happy Harry Potter series, I jumped on board right away. Forrest and I brainstormed a couple different things we could do, and we finally settled on a fun twist on butterbeer – butterbeer creamsicles.

NEVER Miss Another Recipe!

Sign up for our food and recipe newsletter today

  • Free eRecipeBook upon signup
  • Free Meal Planning Bundle
  • Easy and Family Friendly Recipes EVERYONE Will Love!

butterbeer-creamsicles (4 of 4)

Now, I want you to know that this recipe took a lot of testing to get right, but it is absolutely fabulous. Sure, it’s basically sugar, on top of sugar, on top of sugar….but it’s delicious.

At first, we put the cream on the bottom…but that ended up not being thick enough to carry the weight of the popsicle stick. Instead, we put it in first, and then the cream soda/ice cream mixture on top of that, and that worked much better.

We got the last package of popsicle molds at Target, but I would recommend getting ones that have long sticks. It makes it much easier.

Here’s just a brief picture tutorial on how to make these!

butterbeer-creamsicles (1 of 7)

butterbeer-creamsicles (3 of 7)

butterbeer-creamsicles (4 of 7)

butterbeer-creamsicles (5 of 7)butterbeer-creamsicles (6 of 7)

butterbeer-creamsicles (1 of 4)

And for any of you Harry Potter fans out there, be sure to enter this AWESOME Harry Potter-themed giveaway. You can win:

a Rafflecopter giveaway


All we ask is that you be kind. We welcome differing opinions, but any comments containing personal attacks, sarcasm, etc. will be removed immediately. Keyboard warriors aren’t welcome 🙂 All comments are moderated and may take time to be approved. Anything not pertaining specifically to the content of a post will be removed (including comments about ads).


1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.